Monday, June 06, 2005

Monday Matchup: By Special Request

perhaps I'm just being lazy by not thinking of my own matchups this week, cause I actually have another topic I want to stew about today.

However.... I realize I haven't done a match-up in a while.... and I *do* want my readers to know that I actually listen to them, so....

for one week only.... by special request.... I give you the match-up of piano proportions:

ELTON JOHN
vs
BILLY JOEL

Which of these piano men really tinkles out ivories??? Will the RocketMan blast the Big Shot? Will Sir Elton be able to say he's Still Standing after Billy-boy applies some Pressure???


only you can tell, dear readers....

DING DING!!!

12 comments:

Christi said...

Hmmm, I'm not a big fan of either, but I'll go with Elton John, no Billy Joel. No, I don't know. Billy Joel, yes, that's it.

Porq said...

Remember the 80 Olympics?

USA USA USA

I gotsta vote for Billy Joel. Anybody who can get Christie Brinkley ( okay, okay, I'm old!!!) scores points in my book... PLUS the Elton John hits on both sides of the plate. May be a plus for him, but like i said, I'M OLD!!

OINK

Carrie said...

Steph--- I was 8 during the olympics.... AND I'm a hockey fan.... need I say more?


Christi... been meaning to say welcome to the jungle!!!

Daddy--- I thought sir Elton was strictly in favor of the gents? didn't know he was bi. I know *I* wouldn't hook up with him... ew!!!

either way.... I'm still thinking of who I';m voting for.

Book Bums said...

Elton John. His personal life aside, he gives a much better show.

AND..."Someone Saved My Life Tonight" is one of my favorite songs...

carlotta said...

Okay I've seen both in concert and shockingly I think Billy puts on a better show. No one's a bigger fag hag that me and Elton is a big ol' Nelly, but Billy in concert is pretty f-ing awesome. I'm slightly torn though because Elton and Billy both have written some great songs. She's Got a Way and Your Song both melt my heart. Still Billy it is.

Marianna said...

Just cuz he was Knighted doesn't mean anything.

Billy Joel all the way.

Tee/Tracy said...

I've seen Billy Joel in concert and Elton gets on my very last nerve. I vote Billy Joel hands down.

Book Bums said...

I've never felt more alone...

Susie said...

Hmmm. this is TOUGH! The only thing Billy has been hitting lately is the bottle. Or a house with his car. Can he pull it together or will he get bitch-slapped around by Elton? Hell hath no fury like a diva scorned so Elton might have the talons out. He looks like he can get downright NASTY and he is a heavy guy these days... I like both of them.

Ang - How can you hate Crocodile Rock? "Me and Susie had so much fun..."

I'm still thinking...

Elvis said...

All of you people are complete weenies. FOCUS on the QUESTION!
Who will win a FIGHT?

It doesn't matter who has better music or makes you all dreamy or which one takes it up the @$$ better! It's who will beat the hell outta the other?

With that said - Billy will knock the snot outta Sir Elton. He still has the energy, and Sir Elton is just a dumpy old fag. Score One for the common sense department.

Susie said...

elvis - Did someone shit in your Cheerios this morning or what?

Carrie said...

no Susie--- he's naturally that way cause he's my brother....



is it making sense yet?